BSSC CASE UPDATE FOR 30-10-2012: NOW JUSTICE SAMRENDRA PRATAP SINGH WILL HEAR THE CASE
BSSC CASE NO CWJC 10268/2012 NOW HAS BEEN SHIFTED TO HONORABLE JUSTICE SAMRENDRA PRATAP SINGH'S BENCH (COURT NUMBER-4). JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA WILL NOW HEAR DOUBLE BENCH CASES. SO NOW THIS CASE WILL BE HEARD ON 30-10-2012 IN JUSTICE SAMRENDRA PRATP SINGH'S BENCH. THIS CASE HAS BEEN LISTED AT 8TH NUMBER IN ADMISSION-1 LIST (17TH IN OVERALL LIST). SO IT IS TOUGH TO SAY WHAT WILL HAPPEN. NEW JUDGE CAN ORDER SOMETHING ELSE.
CLICK HERE FOR 30-10-2012 CAUSE LIST OF BSSC CASE
BSSC COURT CASE: BSSC CASE HEARING WAS SCHEDULED AT THIRD NUMBER ON 19 OCTOBER. BUT DUE TO SOME REASONS IT WAS SHIFTED IN SECOND HALF. EVEN IN SECOND HALF HEARING DIDN'T TAKE PLACE. IT IS SAID THAT BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION HASN'T SUBMITTED THE MARKS AND ROLL NUMBERS OF PETITIONER'S WHICH WERE DEMANDED BY JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA. IT SEEMS BSSC IS STILL EVALUATING THE OMR SHEETS AFTER DELETE OF 10 QUESTIONS. THEN IT WILL BE IN A POSITION TO REPLY ABOUT THE MARKS OF CANDIDATES. SO, NOW COURT IS CLOSED FOR DURGA POOJA. IT WILL OPEN ON 30-10-2012. YOU CAN HOPE ANYTHING AFTER THAT.
CASE UPDATE FOR 19-10-2012: ON 19-10-2012, PERHAPS ANY ORDER WILL BE PASSED ON BSSC CASE. BSSC CASE IS LISTED AT THIRD NUMBER IN ADMISSION-1 SECTION. SO WAIT FOR ONE MORE DAY FOR ANY ORDER
CLICK HERE FOR 19-10-2012 CAUSE LIST
UPDATE: PATNA HIGH COURT HAS ORDERED BSSC TO SUBMIT ROLL NUMBERS AND MARKS AFTER DELETION OF 10 QUESTIONS. HONOURABLE JUDGE ALSO ASKED BSSC 'HOW MANY PETITIONERS ARE NOW QUALIFYING AFTER DELETION OF 10 QUESTIONS?' BSSC HAD TO SUBMIT ALL THE DOCUMENTS ON 18-10-2012..
AS USUAL CAUSE LIST OCTOBER 18: ONLY REMINDING YOU THAT ONCE AGAIN CASE IS LISTED FOR OCTOBER 18. BUT IT DOESN'T MATTER MUCH. AFTER GOING THROUGH THE WHOLE CAUSE LIST PROCEDURES, I FIND SOME AMAZING THINGS. TWO CASES, WHICH WERE LISTED ON OCTOBER 17 , HAD ALREADY BEEN DISPOSED EARLIER, YET IT WAS LISTED. SIMILARLY, ONE CASE, WHICH WAS ORDERED EARLIER TO BE LISTED ON NOVEMBER 4, WAS LISTED ON OCTOBER 17. DON'T KNOW WHY? SO CAUSE LIST LISTING OF CASES DOESN'T TELL THE WHOLE TRUTH. SOMETHING MAY BE THE PROCEDURES, WHICH WE CAN NOT UNDERSTAND. BUT AFTER ALL IT IS DEPLORABLE.
................................................................................................................................................................
WAIT FOR OCTOBER 17: NOTHING HAPPENED ON OCTOBER 16. CASE CWJC 10268/2012 IS LISTED IN COURT NUMBER 8 ON OCTOBER 17, 2012. CASE IS LISTED AT NUMBER 12 (7TH NUMBER IN ADMISSION 1 LIST). HOWEVER IT ALL DEPENDS ON AAG LALIT KISHORE. IF HE ATTENDS COURT NUMBER 8, THEN HEARING OF THIS CASE WILL TAKE PLACE. OTHERWISE---------------.HOPE SOMETHING EMERGE ON OCTOBER 17.
CLICK HERE FOR OCTOBER 17 CAUSE LIST
CASE UPDATE FOR OCTOBER 16: HONORABLE PRAKASH CHANDDRA VERMA DIDN'T ATTEND THE COURT ON OCTOBER 15. SO NOW CASE WILL BE HEARD ON OCTOBER 16. CASE IS LISTED ON FIRST HALF. SO AFTER 12.15 PM ANY ORDER WILL COME.
CLICK HERE FOR OCTOBER 16 CAUSE LIST
................................................................................................................................................................
CASE UPDATE FOR OCTOBER 15: BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION CASE CWJC 10268/2012 WILL BE HEARD ON OCTOBER 15 IN PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA'S BENCH. MOST PROBABLY ANY ORDER WILL BE PASSED ON THAT DAY. SO YOUR LONG WAIT MAY BE OVER ON OCTOBER 15.
CLICK HERE FOR OCTOBER 15 CAUSE LIST
CASE UPDATE FOR OCTOBER 12: JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA DIDN'T ATTEND THE COURT ON 11-10-2012. SO NO HEARING TOOK PLACE IN HIS BENCH. ON 12-10-2012 CAUSE LIST OF PATNA HIGH COURT, JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA'S BENCH HASN'T FIND ANY MENTION. HIS BENCH'S CASES ARE NOT SHOWING IN THE 12-10-2012 LIST. THANKS
| Present Status of case ( CWJC-10268/2012 ): |
| Case No.: | CWJC-10268/2012 | Bench: | |
| Filed on: | 31 May 2012 | District: | PATNA |
SUBHASH PASWAN & ORS
Vs.
BIHAR STAFF SELECTION COMMISSI | Subject: | SELECTION , NON GAZETTED SER. |
| P.S.Case No.: | |
| Lower Court: | -0- |
| For Admission | 09 Oct 2012 -> ADJOURNED TO 11 Oct 2012 |
| Petitioner's Advocate: | DINU KUMAR | ADMISSION MATTER |
| Respondent Advocate: | PARTH SHARTHI SC10 | ** Pending **
|
| In the Court of: | N/A |
| Listed at serial 0, For Admission BEFORE :- MR. JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA |
..................................................................................................................................................
BPSC 53-55 MARKING PATTERN
UPDATE: CASE WAS LISTED ON 11-10-2012 AT 16TH NUMBER. SO HEARING WILL TAKE PLACE AFTER 11 AM AND SOMETHING CAN BE EXPECTED BEFORE 12.30 PM.
CLICK HERE FOR BSSC CASE 11-10-2012 CAUSE LIST
.................................................................................................................................................
CASE UPDATE: NEXT DATE 11-10-2012
CASE WAS LISTED IN FIRST HALF ON 09-10-2012 (FIFTH NUMBER WHICH MEANS WITHIN ONE HOUR OF COURT OPENING). BSSC DEMANDED TWO DAYS MORE TO SUBMIT IT'S RESPONSE IN THE WAKE OF 10 QUESTIONS DELETION. IT IS EVALUATING THE CONSEQUENCES AFTER DELETION. THEN IT WILL BE IN A POSITION TO TELL THE COURT, WHAT SITUATIONS WILL EMERGED AFTER FOLLOWING 4 OCTOBER ORDER. BE POSITIVE, CUT OFF IS GOING TO BE LOWERED, BUT AT WHAT EXTENT, ONLY HONOURABLE JUDGE WILL BE IN A POSITION TO TELL. BUT ONE THING IS CLEAR THAT PETITIONER'S ADVOCATE HAS CATEGORICALLY STATED IN THE COURT THAT NO PASSED STUDENT SHOULD BE FAILED. HENCE THOSE WHO ARE IN A RANGE OF 315 TO 341 SCORE (IN GENERAL CATEGORY), HAVE A FARE CHANCE OF APPEARING IN THE MAINS EXAMINATION. MAINS EXAMINATION MIGHT BE HELD IN THE MONTH OF DECEMBER-JANUARY.
.........................................................................................................................................................
CLICK HERE FOR CAUSE LIST IN PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA BENCH
OPTIONS BEFORE THE HIGH COURT AND THE BSSC
CLICK HERE FOR HIGH COURT ORDER DATED 04-10-2012
Hearing took place on 04-10-2012. According to the advocate
of petitioner, hearing will once again resume on 09-10-2012, and chances are
that case will be admitted on that date. Here admission means judgment. Honorable Justice Prakash Chandra Verma suggested BSSC to delete the
controversial 10 questions from the booklet. One question had been deleted by
BSSC before declaration of result. It means, now full marks will be 556 (139
questions) instead of 596 (149 questions).
Earlier cut-off for general category was 342, which is bound to go
lower. Now following new scenarios have
emerged:
1. Those students who were penalized due to wrong answers, will
get extra one mark on each question due to negative marking deduction.
2. Those who were awarded 4 marks (successful or unsuccessful)
on each question (out of 10 deleted questions) will suffer more.
3. In these scenarios cut-off will come down.
Now options: Going through the whole matter, it seems that there
are three options left before the honorable judge on which BSSC will proceed
further. Honorable Judge might order:
1.
After deletion of 10 questions, prepare fresh
merit list, limiting the qualified students five times of total seats: In this
scenario some passed students will be failed and some unsuccessful will be
declared qualified for mains examination.
2.
Follow BPSC case (CWJC 13022/2011) and don’t
disqualify those who have been declared qualified earlier, in this process if some
unsuccessful candidates find place, let them allow appearing in the mains examination. In
this case in each category score of last student (according to merit) will be fixed
as a cut-off and some unsuccessful students, who will be scoring on par with the
cut off or more will be declared qualified.
3. Lower the cutoff by 40 marks (for 10 deleted
questions) in respective categories. This option was followed in Bihar
Judiciary Examination conducted by BPSC. In this case cut-off for general category will
be 302 marks. If this happens then more than 25000 students will appear in the
mains examination.
Now all the options are open. It is up to the Honorable
judge to order. We can only speculate on all these options. Wait for October 9.
NEWS UPDATE:
CASE WILL BE HEARD ON 04-10-2012. CASE NO. 10268 WILL BE HEARD ON FIRST HALF. SO, FRIENDS BE READY FOR JUDGEMENT.
FOR ADMISSION I
CWJC/10268/2012
SELECTION , NON GAZETT 1
SUBHASH PASWAN & ORS
VS. BIHAR STAFF SELECTION
COMMISSION & ORS
If we go through the history of Bihar SSC first graduate
level (Sachiwalay Sahayak) examination process, it looks like a ‘BSSC Five Year
Plan’. Posts were advertised in 2010,
preliminary examination was held in 2011 (December), preliminary result was
declared in 2012 (April). Right now we
are near end of 2012. It doesn’t look like that this process is going to end
very soon. Neither BSSC is proceeding
further, nor is High court taking this case seriously. We shouldn’t forget that
high court hasn’t stayed the process. It means that BSSC is not bound to
maintain status quo. It is well known that BSSC has corrected the model answer
and has prepared the revised result. It
should publish either additional result or revised result. But it seems, it is
not serious to move ahead, otherwise it should have requested to honorable high
court to take the matter seriously, since it is effecting the functioning of
state government. So, almost three years have passed since, two more years are
left in five years. Will this whole process take two more years? Nobody knows!
Who cares the future of Bihar unemployed youths? Let us hope for better.
..............................................................................................................................................................
CASE UPDATE
It seems either of the two advocates (Either
Petitioner's or Respondent's) is engaged in some other cases that is why he is
not available for this case. On 14-09-2012 one of the advocates (most probably
AAG Lalit Kishore) prayed for adjournment, and so granted. But it seems that he
is still not arranging time for this case, otherwise this case might have
admitted on 18-09-2012. You can check the order of CWJC 10268/2012 from this link. So wait for his availability for this case.
ON SEPTEMBER 19, 2012, ONCE AGAIN CASE NO. CWJC 10268/ 2012 WAS NOT LISTED IN CAUSE LIST. SO NO HEARING TOOK PLACE ON SEPTEMBER 19, 2012. Keep Waiting.
On September 18, 2012, case was to be listed and was to
be admitted in Prakash Chandra Verma’s bench. But unfortunately it didn’t find
place in final cause list. Hearing was to be resumed but this case was
not listed in Cause list. You may call it clerical error or whatever else, but
it is indeed pathetic and it tells the real story of our Indian Judiciary
particularly Bihar Judiciary. Wait more days. One day it will find a place in cause
list. So this is update for today. I will update you as soon as I
find any update regarding this case. Thanks.
(Note: However it is showing in CIS Cause list, but that is
not the final cause list and that is not updated. In CIS cause list it is
mentioned at 305 number but that don’t tells the real story or final cause
list.)
Old news
HEARING WILL RESUME ON SEPTEMBER 18
BSSC CWJC 10268/2012 CASE WAS LISTED ON 14-09-2012. BSSC
PRESENTED ITS STATUS AND PETITIONERS ADVOCATE DINU KUMAR ALSO ARGUED. AFTER
LISTENING BOTH PARTIES HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA VERMA ORDERED TO
CONTINUE ARGUMENT ON 18-09-2012. ON 17-09-2012 HIGH COURT IS CLOSED DUE TO VISWAKARMA POOJA. SO HEARING OF BSSC FIRST
GRADUATE LEVEL RESULT WILL RESUME ON 18-09-2012 (TUESDAY). KEEP YOUR FINGER
CROSSED.
FOR ADMISSION
-------------
0. CWJC 10268-2012 SUBHASH PASWAN & ORS Mr.DINU KUMAR Mr.PARTH SHARTHI SC10
SELECTION , N vs BIHAR STAFF SELECTION Mr.ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA Mr.SAJID SALIM KHAN
Mr.SHIW KUMAR PRABHAKAR Mr.SATYAM SHIVAM SUNDARAM
Mr.SATYABIR BHARTI
0. CWJC 10683-2012 RINA KUMARI Mr.ABHIMANYU SHARMA Mr.SATYAM SHIVAM SUNDARAM
SELECTION , N vs THE BIHAR STAFF SELEC Mr.SANJAY KUMAR SINGH Mr.SATYABIR BHARTI
Mr.UDAI SHANKAR SINGH,Mr.
0. CWJC 12209-2012 AFZAL KARIM & ORS Mr.SHIW KUMAR PRABHAKAR Mr.DEVENDRA KR SINHA AAG2
SELECTION , N vs BIHAR STAFF SELECTION Mr.ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA Mr.SHIV KUMAR
Mr.SATYAM SHIVAM SUNDARAM
Mr.SATYABIR BHARTI
