CURRENT QUIZ: हाल में गृह मंत्रालय ने 'बिजली गिरना' आपदा को अधिसूचित आपदा की सूची में शामिल करने की सिफारिश 14वे वित्त आयोग से की है***बिहार के तेलहड़ा में प्राचीनतम विश्वविद्यालय के प्रमाण प्राप्त हुए ***मराठा मंदिर सिनेमा हॉल मे 'दिलवाले दुल्हनिया ले जायेंगे' लगातार १०००० सप्ताह दिखाने का रिकॉर्ड बनाया ***21 जून को 'अंतराष्ट्रीय योग दिवस' मनाया जायेगा ***इबोला से लड़ने वाले डॉक्टर्स एवं नर्सों को टाइम पर्सन ऑफ़ दी ईयर २०१५ घोषित किया गया***भारत ने पहली बार अपना युद्धक पोत किसी देश को निर्यात करने का निर्णय किया. उस युद्धक पोत का क्या नाम है? (सीजीएस बैराकुडा)***भारत ने पहली बार अपना युद्धक पोत (सीजीएस बैराकुडा) किसी देश को निर्यात करने का निर्णय किया. उस देश का क्या नाम है? (मॉरीशस)***भारतीय दंड संहिता की वह धारा जिसके तहत आत्महत्या को गैर आपराधिक बनाया गया है? (धारा ३०९)***विश्व बैंक की एक शाखा "मिगा " का १८१ वां सदस्य कौन सा देश बना है(भूटान)***'उबर' जिस पर केंद्र सरकार ने दिल्ली में ऍप्स टैक्सी सेवा उपलब्ध कराने पर प्रतिबन्ध लगा दिया, किस देश की कंपनी है? (यूएसए)***अंतराष्ट्रीय भ्रस्टाचार निरोधी दिवस किस तिथि को मनाया जाता है? (9 दिसम्बर )***वह तिथि जिस दिन प्रथम विश्व मृदा दिवस मनाया गया:(5 दिसंबर)***हाल में अंतरास्ट्रीय अपराध अदालत ने उहरु केन्याता के खिलाफ युद्ध अपराध से सम्बंधित आरोप वापस ले लिए. उहरु केन्याता किस देश के राष्ट्रपति हैं? (केन्या)***वह देश जिसे दिसम्बर के प्रथम सप्ताह में पेयजल संकट के समाधान हेतु भारत ने बड़ी मात्र में पेयजल के आपूर्ति की?(मालदीव)***न्यू होराइजन्स किस आकाशीय पिंड के अध्ययन हेतु भेजा गया नासा का अभियान है? (प्लूटो )***हाल में कौन खिलाडी एकदिवसीय क्रिकेट में १०००० रन बनाने वाले विश्व के चौथे बल्लेबाज बने: (कुमार संगकारा)***वह केंद्रीय मंत्री और लोकसभा संसद जिनके बयानों के कारण संसद का दोनों सदन कई दिनों तक वाधित रहा: (साध्वी निरंजना ज्योति)*** भारत ने किस देश को पराजित कर दृष्टिहीनों का क्रिकेट विश्व कप २०१४ जीता: (पाकिस्तान )***इसरो ने किस तिथि को जीसैट 16 फ्रेंच गुयाना के कोउरू के अरियन-5 यान से प्रक्षेपित किया (7 दिसंबर )**थर्टी मीटर टेलिस्कोप परियोजना का पूर्ण सदस्य बना भारत***अरुण मजूमदार अमेरिका का विज्ञानं दूत बनें ***

Sunday, September 1, 2013

BPSC 53-55th: Result out, Moderation issue in Double Bench and Post Mortem report with student


Hearing news 11-09-2013: Honorable court has demanded moderate marks and raw marks (original marks given by examiner) of students from BPSC. Next hearing on 1st October.

(Hearing on BPSC Moderation case has started. First hearing took place on 10 September in double bench of Patna High Court headed by honorable Chief Justice Rekha M. Doshit. BPSC said that it has already declared the final result, but petitioners  advocates countered BPSC and said that when case was referred to larger bench, why final result was declared? Hearing will be continued for few more days.)

I had mentioned in one of my posts that moderation case was pending with larger bench, although written stay was not there yet morality says that result should not be published but BPSC morality-----. My apprehension proved right. It is irony that when UPSC has introduced ethics, morality and human value in Civil Services mains syllabus, one public service commission is joking with these issues. We shouldn't forget that two months before mains examination result declaration, BPSC hosted symposium of all public service commissions in which UPSC also participated. But I have already said that talking about BPSC morality, is nothing but wasting your time, hence I am focusing on main points.
No doubt final result is published, and some may argue that now everything is over, and frankly speaking, they are not wrong altogether. But that doesn't mean chapter is closed. Honorable Chief Justice is going to hear the moderation case (CWJC 9569/2013), most probably from 2nd September, 2013. BPSC has already published the marks of candidates (CLICK HERE FOR YOUR MAINS MARKSHEET), and students (those fighting against BPSC’s so called unjust moderation) are equipped with more proofs. These proofs might prove fatal for BPSC (I might be too optimistic), if honorable Double bench doesn’t sympathize with BPSC. Only one thing that is in favor of BPSC is that it has already completed it's process. On this basis it might plead to reject the case, and in earlier occasions, BPSC has succeeded  getting relief on this bais. But moderation case is different ball game. Honorable Justice Ravi Ranjan has himself said clearly that BPSC moderation is bogus, and he even said that BPSC should have followed scaling method. He referred it to larger bench seeing the intensity of the case. Hence it cannot be said that ‘Process Complete’ argue is going to help BPSC.  BPSC proceeded on its own, neither students nor court is responsible for that. BPSC itself is responsible for that; it has to pay the price. Why every time poor students will pay for BPSC’s fault?  From preliminary examination to interview level, it has committed blunders. Here are some of the blunders:
1.       In preliminary examination, more than 10 questions were deleted: students paid for it
2.       BPSC conducted mains examination simultaneously with JPSC mains examination: students paid for it.
3.       Moderation: In Mathematics and Chemistry some students scored more than 180 marks out of 200, and in philosophy some students scored only 5. Can you believe it? How a student of humanity can compare with mathematics and Chemistry? Which type of moderation was adopted? Patna high court had ordered (Justice Katriar) BPSC to follow moderation and scaling seeing the boom factor. But this time some other subjects outperformed some other subjects. Nothing changed: students paid the price.
4.       Some physically handicapped (General) candidates are saying that their marks are more than the written cut off, yet they were not called for interview. Even the gap between written cut off and final cut off for general physically handicapped is 205. How can one score 200 out of 150?
These are some of the examples which show BPSC’s “HUM NAHI SUDHRENGE” approach. But one should not forget that now we are leaving in virtual world and RTI world, where social media is too active and it has a capability to create a movement against wrongdoings. BPSC fighter group is one of such movements which are fighting against injustice caused to the candidates. It is duty of all interest group to come forward and fight against the injustice done by BPSC, so that next generation couldn’t face similar situation. 

23 comments:

Zakir said...

thanks Ratish ji.....but when BPSC has finalised the result,i think court willnt interfere the result....and....BPSC will continue its monopoly.....plz share ur views on BSSC sachivalaya sahayek result too

justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Rahul Roy said...

It is 7th sep now. There is no update about the case. What's the use of such blog website.

niraj singh said...

Today BPSC moderation hearing took place in the chief justice bench. During hearing, when bpsc advocate lalit kishore said that process has been completed, then senior advocate girijee and kanthjee asked him that when case was pending in the larger bench, then why he declared the result? Students adovate also asked whether bpsc was sure that case would be in its favor, so that it declared the result? Hearing will continue tomorrow.

Jhon said...

Niraj sir aap court mai ye bhi baat ko bataye ki kis aadhar pe bahut sare candidate ko interview mai 50 ya usse bhi kam marks mile h..maine dekha ki mains cut off of se 50 maks se jyada hone par bhi seletion nhi ho paya.qki interview mai 50 ya usse bhi kam mile h...mai bhi isme shamil hoo.mera cut off se 53 marks jyada the..firbhi slection nhi ho paya....

justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
balam pichkari said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
chandra bhushan gupta said...

kaya hua aaj court me?

chandra bhushan gupta said...

kaya interview me koi minimum marks dene ka koi provision nahi hai.moderation kaise kiya gaya?kaya personal target kiya gaya hai?plz bataye.

mahaku ram said...

ab double bench case se kuch na hoga,bpsc ne final result nikal diya bhanta paka ke.,haathi ke lund ki tarah case kartie raho chutar patak ke mahakhu ram chala joining karnie bhanta paka ke

justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Nisprih said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
justice said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Jhon said...

shahnawaz khan ka bhi board bahut kharab tha.

rakesh said...

Its really a matter of high level manipulation and corruption.This time some gud news should come, either from high court or supreme cour

rakesh said...

Its really a matter of high level manipulation and corruption.This time some gud news should come, either from high court or supreme cour

INDIAN said...

हेल्लो , सलाम , प्रणाम ....

BPSC ने जो आधा-अधूरा फर्जी डाटा २ दिन पहले कोर्ट को दिया है उसकी जांच पड़ताल बहुत बारीकी से की जा रही है और हमारा केस अब और मजबूत हो गया है.

हमको न्याय मिलना है ये निश्चित है बस देखने वाली बात ये है की वो न्याय-मूर्ति कौन होगा और वो दिन कबका होगा

हमारे पटना के साथी अपने दाना पानी सब दरकिनार करके bpsc के डाटा का postmortam कर रहे हैं और अब एक ऐसा फाइनल जवाब बनाया जा रहा है जो BPSC की धूर्तता को पीस कर मिट्टी में मिला देगा.

आप सब से बस येही अनुरोध है की हमारे फाइटर ग्रुप को आर्थिक हेल्प करते रहिये.

S.B.I. बैंक अकाउंट डिटेल्स-
ACCOUNT NAME- SARVESH CHANDRA
ACCOUNT NO.- 32502534457
STATE BANK OF INDIA, A. G. COLONY BRANCH, PATNA.

FOR MORE DETAILS CALL-
09335306283, 07897352695

हो सकता है ये फाइट हम सुप्रीम कोर्ट से जीतेंगे, लेकिन हम ही जीतेंगे ये तय है

Anonymous said...

I heared that bpsc mains exam of 53 to 55th may be canceal by supreme court in next coming 1 or 2 hearing . is it true or this only speculation.