Thursday, July 18, 2013

BPSC MODERATION: WHAT HONORABLE JUSTICE RAVI RANJAN SAID


 

Honorable Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan order regarding BPSC moderation on 53-55th mains examination (CWJC 9569/2013, 9674/2013 and many more) is now on public domain. However, all details of hearing are not in order copy, and also honorable Justice hasn’t passed any judgment, except accepting references of Honorable apex court judgment and referring it to the honorable Chief Justice of Patna High Court. In whole order copy, one is petitioner’s views and one is BPSC counsel view. Only at one point Justice Ravi Ranjan has accepted that apex court has said that moderation is not sufficient in case where multi-subjects examination is held. Honorable Ravi Ranjan said:

From perusal of the aforesaid it would appear that the Apex Court has come to the conclusion that the procedure of moderation would only solve the problem of examiner Variability, where the examiners are many but valuation of answer-scripts in respect of a single subject is done and all the subjects are compulsory, however, moderation would be no answer where the problem would be to find out inter se merit across the subjects where examination has been conducted in different subjects. It has been held that, in order to solve the problem of inter se merit across different subjects, statistical experts have evolved a method known as scaling that is creation of a common scale. On that pretext it is being urged that, since admittedly, the Bihar Public Service Commission had adopted method of moderation for bringing uniformity which has already been held insufficient and improper in such examination by the Apex Court where different subjects are to be opted by different candidates, that has resulted in disparity in the scoring by the candidates in the different subjects.”

It also says “It is submitted that the Bihar Public Service Commission has adopted moderation and not the method of scaling in violation of the direction of the Division Bench contained in Annexure 6 which was passed on the basis of the judgment of the Apex Court in the judgment of Sanjay Singh (supra).”

One more thing, Justice Ravi Ranjan also mentioned Prashant Ramesh Chakrawar (supra) case. But let me remind you that in that case 6 steps of moderation is mentioned, and this judgment came in February 2013. But at that point of time, BPSC has already moderated answer sheets of students. Because in its affidavit BPSC clearly said that decision on moderation was taken in mid January 2013. It clears that BPSC violated the double bench order which has said until you make any rule, follow Sanjay Singh direction of Supreme Court. As said above that in Sanjay Singh case Supreme Court has favored scaling in those examinations where optional papers exist. It is also clear that (according to BPSC affidavit) so far BPSC hasn’t framed any rule regarding moderation or scaling. It means no rules were framed then Sanjay Singh (supra) order has to be followed. Even Chakrawar steps were not followed. BPSC didn’t followed any steps, because honorable Justice had said BPSC counsel during hearing that you didn’t prepare a model answer which was one of the steps of Chakrawar moderation formula.

Second and more important, BPSC has clearly stated in its affidavit that moderation was done on those students who scored more than 60% marks and less than 30% marks. This has not been mentioned in order copy. But one must not forget that after repeatedly asking, BPSC didn’t elaborate its process of moderation.  Hence this serious issue is going to be raised in the larger bench.

 One can draw many conclusions, but matter is serious and has to be dealt carefully. That is why Honorable Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan has referred it to the larger bench, where most probably Honorable the Chief Justice of Patna High Court Rekha M. Doshit will chair the bench. Since no written stay is there, hence BPSC might declare the final result, but BPSC counsel has promised the Judge (Dr. Justice Ravi Ranjan) that no result will be published until case is  resolved, even BPSC is also saying that until case is pending no result will come. Let us see whether oral promise of stay is maintained which needs moral. About BPSC morality------?
 

 

 

30 comments:

Lee said...

Mr. Ratish Jha do you have any moral value, if you dont know the complete things then why you are making issue , and I also feel without moderation result should come so you will understand your position, if scaling was done then also you people were in the court....and if you were so concerned then whynot you reported reservation's case earlier....so this show ur morality....i am free to comment since we are residing in a democratic country.

Lee said...

I know this comment you are going to delete

Unknown said...

dear,ratish jee first of all a big thank u for providing us such a valuable information.and secondly,there is a request to all of my friends specially,niraj singh,sathi mitra,abhishek raj,aiok kumar,jayesh bhai etc that this is right time for right action.so plz guide us with ur valuable thinking.

Unknown said...

Very good update ratish jee....Bpsc ko apni galtiyon ko sudharna hi hoga...agar 5% bhi sudhar hota hai to 50% shrey aapke is blog ko jayega...aapne bahut achhe kam kiye hain..ho sakta hai 2% log aapki aalochna bhi karen..lekin vyapak hit me kaam karne wale chhoti-chhoti aalochna ko dhuyen ke saath udaa dete hain....so,keep updating and mobilising the student who suffered illogical moderation of bpsc....

rajesh bihari said...

aap me se kisi ko yadi malum ho ki result kb aa rha hai to plz batayiye.

rajesh bihari said...

sach to ye hai ki yha koi v kisi ki hit ki bat nhi krta sabhi swarthi hai.are yar thori si comon sense lagao adhikari ke koun se gun dikh rahe hai bloger me.neta ban rha hai.yar jiwan bhar safalta ki swad n chakh sakane wale hai.bari bari bate krenge padhai to hoti nhi ab budho se.achha bhala result ko delay kra diye sb

rajesh bihari said...

hum aaye hai ab kranti hogi.aayog ko badalane wale behater hai khud ko badale.sb ko santust kiya ja skta hai mathadisho ko nhi.

rajesh bihari said...

jaha hum hote hai wha sirf hum hote hai.

rajesh bihari said...

mujhe v uksaya gaya ki blog join kro.yar in mathadisho se sbko swadhan kro.

Unknown said...

Bhai log ye sab afwah ratish bhai uda rahe hai taki unka blog gulzar bana rahe, unhe bpsc ke result se koi matlab nhi hai, wo to chahte hai ki result khub latke aur unka blog failure candidates se gulzar bana rahe

Unknown said...

case karne wale student hi bpsc ko 5 year plan bana deten hain.moderation karo to moderation kyon kiye. na karo to kyon nahi kiya. moderation karo to scaling kyon nahi scaling karo to moderation kyon nahi. lekin nischit hai ki kisi bhi halat me in type ladkon ka selection nahi hone wala hai. ratish jha jee khud iske bahut bade prawakta hai unhe bpsc ke naam se blog na likha karen fighter grp ke naam se blog likhen. saathi mitra jaise log khud to mehnat karenge nahi sirf dusre ko kosten rahenge. moderation hatne pe bhi usi ka marks aur badhega jiska selection hua hai.

Unknown said...

ratish jha jee hum sab aapke blog ko pichle 2 year se follow kar rahen hain lekin aapne apne blog se sabon ka maan tod diya. bekar type ki baat likhte rahte hain. moderation ka matlab bhi pata hai aapko. moderation se nischit hi usi ka marks bdega jo select hue hain. selection usi ka hua hain jisne aacha likha hai. bacchon jaisi baat karna aur apwah failna band karen. kam se kam apne blog ke follower ka dhyan to karen.

jagdar said...

Rathis ji ko kosna bekar h bhai. Maanta hu interview dene waale frustate hue h ki result nahi nikala. Par is sthiti ke jimmedar hami log h. Hum reality ko accept karne ko taiyaar n hue.blog par kuchh ladko jaise jayesh ne bar- bar samjhaya ki abhi result nahi nikalega par hum n maane.ab dekho aaplog kal result aana bol rahe ho. Dekho kal bhi aata h yaa ye bhi aaplogo ka hawai kila nikalta h. He bhagwaan result kab aayega ?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

इस रिजल्ट के बचने की अब कोई संभावना नही है मित्रों .. जो लोग बीपीएससी के सरगर्मियों पर नजर रखते हैं उन्हें मालुम है कि अब वहां इस बात पर मंथन हो रहा है कि इस गड़बड़ झाले का जिम्मेदार कौन है ? किसी न किसी को तो बलि का बकरा बनाया ही जाएगा .. देखिये, जब मनमाने ढंग से मार्क्स घटाने बढाने का खेल मोडरेशन के नाम पर किया गया है तो मोडरेशन की आड़ में न जाने कैसे कैसे भ्रष्टाचार किए गए होंगे ?हो सकता है कि पैसे या पैरवी से मार्क्स घटाए बढाए गए हों .. अब मात्र मोडरेशन समाप्त करने का मामला ही नही बल्कि इस के नाम पर चले भ्रष्टाचार का मामला भी स्पष्ट नजर आने लगा है .. बहुत संभव है कि लार्जर बेंच इस मामले को इस एंगल से भी देखेगी .. सीबीआई इन्क्वायरी का आदेश अगर आ गया तो मामला बहुत दिनों के लिए भी लटक सकता है .. भविष्य का मुख्य गुण ही अनिश्चितता को माना जाता है .. कुछ भी हो सकता है ..इतना तो तय है कि इस भ्रष्ट व्यवस्था को जाना ही होगा .... बीपीएससी के पास मात्र एक ही रास्ता बचा है ..वह स्वयं इंटरनल इन्क्वायरी कर दोषियों को दण्डित करे और ६०% से अधिक अंक वालों को भी इंटरव्यू देने के लिए बुलाए .. टकराव का रास्ता स्वयं बीपीएससी के अधिकारियों के लिए मुश्किलें खड़ा कर सकता है .. इश्वर उन्हें सदबुद्धि दे

Unknown said...

dosto result ke liye sathiyon ko blame karna kahaan tak uchit hai?ratish jee ya kisi aur ko blame karna samasya ka samadhan nahi ho sakta.jaldibaji main aakar dusron ke upar tippani karna aap jaise maryadit logo ko shobha nahin deta.blog ki maryada barkarar rakhain.ummid hai aap sabhi asli doshi ko jante honge.aapsi shauhard banayein rakhain.ese apne bhai ki taraf se ek request samjhain.

ajaydavid said...

THis is all bullshit.yahi sab chalta raha toh Bihar aur Pichad jaayega,aacche log jo kuch kaam karna chatei hain wo kabhi aisha system join nahi karenge.

Kuch bewakuf logon ke wajah se ye sab case pe case chalta rehta hai ,aur BPSC ki ye haalat ho gayi hai. Abki pata nahi phir kab result niklei kab next BPSC notification niklei.

Anonymous said...

aapna roll no. post kar ke dekh lo bhai pata chal jaaega ki koun bevkuf hai ..apna roll no aane vaale result me dhundhte rah jaaaoge

Unknown said...

MR.RATISH JHA JI,,
aapse vinamr nivedan hai ki aap NISHPAKCH hokar likhe..kripeya one side hokar n likhe,,aapko dono side ki baat likhni chahie,,lekin aap kewal one side hi likhte hai...mai LEE ko badhai dena chahta hu ki unhone aapni baat bahut democratic tarke se rakhi hai...THANX ,,TO LEE....LEE

rajesh bihari said...

baikuf tum nhi ho lekin insan nhi ho.khud k swarth k liye hajro nirdos ko presan kr rhe ho.result nhi aaye usase sirf tum khush hoge lekin jo besabri se intjar kr rha hai uspe kya gujregi.tum nhi samajh paoge kyu ki tum us layak ho hi nhi.ratish ka blog hai o khud .......................hai

jagdar said...

E bihari ji , rathis babu pe kahe gavuaaaa rahe h ji. Jo aap log ko sach ka Rasta dikhaye Usi par tut padte h aaplogan. Aaj resultawa aayega na, ham ta sweets kharid laaya hun baalusahi 1 kilo, saanjh ko batunga......aap ko bhi khilaunga telephone par.ram ram mahaku ram.

Unknown said...

what happened in reservation case
Rajesh khanna

Unknown said...

what happened in reservation case
Rajesh khanna

Unknown said...

BPSC autonomous body hai,,koi bhi sanstha isko nirdesh nahi desakti ki aap scaling or moderation aapnaie...isko jo suitabe lagega aur neyay sammat hoga wo formula aapnane ke lie sowatantra hai,,,india ke kai state me scaling lagu hai to kai state me moderation ko aapnaya jata hai,,,supreme court ka kahna hai ki scaling system aapne aap me vivaditi hai..islie BPSC ne chatron ke hit me kaam kiya hai..dosto..nirash hone ki bilkul jarurat nahi hai..

Unknown said...

dear veer ji,aap to khud hi court ban gaye.faisala sunane ke liye dhanyawad

Unknown said...

aur bahiyo kya ho raha hai??????????koi nai baat batao?bpsc to chutiya hai hi nahi to itna bakheda nahi khada hota.

Unknown said...

PT वाले केस पर BPSC अत्तिरिक्त रिजल्ट देने पर सहमत हो गयी है ......वह ऐसे दुबारा सफल होने वाले लोगो का अलग से mains और इंटरव्यू लेने के लिए राजी हो गयी है .....प्राप्त सुचना के अनुसार केस करने वाले लोग सभी लोगों का फिर से मुख्य परीक्षा लेने पर जोर दे रहें हैं......नवनीति बाबु ने आपस में सलाह करने के लिए एक सप्ताह का समय दिए हैं .....देखिये अगले सप्ताह में क्या होता है ....

Unknown said...

In PT case, BPSC is agree to publish extra result and hold seperate mains examination, but Honorable Judge is rigid to declare fresh preliminary result and hold fresh mains of all candidates. Even petitioners are rigid that no separate mains examination should be held but single mains for all. Judge gave BPSC one week time, judgment on 29th July.

Unknown said...

Dosto es blog per likha jaa raha hai ke bpsc ne pt me reservation ko follow nahi kiya. pt dubara hoga, main dubara hoga, pt case monster ke taraha bahar nikla, is prakar ki ulti sidhi afvaho se dur rahe. bpsc ne 100% sahi reservation policy ko follow kiya hai vahi kiya hai jo bihar serkar ke karmik vibag ka adesh tha. aur bpsc apne stand per hi kayam rehegi. jap bpsc ne pt first time me result diya tha to reservation ko puri tarah se follow kiya gaya us samay sirf ek hi vivad tha ki kuch prasn galat hain lekin uske bad court ke nirnay ke anusar galat quition ko dilit karte hua revise reult diya gaya. revise result ke anusar prarambh me kuch pt pass candidate ko bahar hona chahiya tha lekin court ne saf kaha tha jin candidate ko pahle hi pass declare kiya gaya hai unhe bahar na kiya jay. isi karan se pt ka yah vivad samne aa raha hai. bpsc 100% vahi result degi jo usne all ready prepre kar rakha hai.

INDIAN said...

हेल्लो , सलाम , प्रणाम ....

BPSC ने जो आधा-अधूरा फर्जी डाटा २ दिन पहले कोर्ट को दिया है उसकी जांच पड़ताल बहुत बारीकी से की जा रही है और हमारा केस अब और मजबूत हो गया है.

हमको न्याय मिलना है ये निश्चित है बस देखने वाली बात ये है की वो न्याय-मूर्ति कौन होगा और वो दिन कबका होगा

हमारे पटना के साथी अपने दाना पानी सब दरकिनार करके bpsc के डाटा का postmortam कर रहे हैं और अब एक ऐसा फाइनल जवाब बनाया जा रहा है जो BPSC की धूर्तता को पीस कर मिट्टी में मिला देगा.

आप सब से बस येही अनुरोध है की हमारे फाइटर ग्रुप को आर्थिक हेल्प करते रहिये.

S.B.I. बैंक अकाउंट डिटेल्स-
ACCOUNT NAME- SARVESH CHANDRA
ACCOUNT NO.- 32502534457
STATE BANK OF INDIA, A. G. COLONY BRANCH, PATNA.

FOR MORE DETAILS CALL-
09335306283, 07897352695

हो सकता है ये फाइट हम सुप्रीम कोर्ट से जीतेंगे, लेकिन हम ही जीतेंगे ये तय है